Isn’t Shepherd’s Devotion the Most Random Broken Thing?

It’s not like Neverwinter is short of balancing flaws or bugs, but today I’d like to talk about a specific Insignia Bonus that continues to reign although it’s clearly hilariously and unnecessarily overpowered.

[su_box title=”Shepherd’s Devotion” radius=”0″]Whenever you use a Daily power, your teammates Defense, Deflection, and Movement are increased by 5% of your Power for 10 seconds.[/su_box]

Shepherd’s Devotion grants all teammates Defense, Deflection, and Movement based on a percentage of your power. Based on today’s stat levels, that’s already nice. Even 12k toons are able to bring 30-40k power to the table, which equates to 5% free damage mitigation for your party. Now, if everybody uses the bonus in a dungeon, you’re talking about a 25% enhancement. Again: That’s already nice and probably would be enough to pick Shepherd’s Devotion on any support toon.

Free Mitigation Cap for Everyone!

What makes the bonus silly overpowered though is the fact that it scales off buffed power! So those powerhouse PVE DCs and DPS with 200k Power can easily transfer. 15%-20% of extra damage mitigation to their teammates. I mean what?! So you basically only need three players in a party to bring the whole team to the damage mitigation caps. Even tanks (even tanks!!!) don’t actually need to stack any defensive stats outside Life Steal if they primarily run with potent players that use Shepherd’s Devotion. That’s by all means not the only reason, but still a massive contributor of why the support meta works.

Now look, balancing mistakes happen. Some Insignia Bonuses suck, others are in every loadout. That’s not so much about the devs not having a clue but more about offering a wide range of different bonuses from which specific ones simply fit the current play style and meta way better. Think enchantments for example. Anybody seriously using Darks other than in utility slots? That’s the same “issue”.

Why Isn’t It Fixed?

So yeah, you can’t anticipate everything, but if you let power proc of buffed stats, bad things are simply bound to happen. And well, even if it develops in to an issue, there’s no need to not fix it relatively fast. Letting Shepherd’s Devotion only proc off base power would already help. It keeps the bonus relevant, but would take away the “wtf” aspect. And in a second step you can then think about further adjustments (if needed).

And please don’t discount the impact. The devs already acknowledged that they have to build dungeons based on the power creep, which isn’t ideal. Content featuring more damage you can’t dodge or mitigate is no coincidence. It’s because otherwise players simply don’t die any longer (and haven’t been dying for a long time). So you’re basically choosing to build your content on top of broken mechanics. Which also means once fixed, dungeons might become too hard. In a very weird way you’re validating stuff like Shepherd’s Devotion by releasing content that requires it although it’s completely nuts. You don’t actually need the Insignia Bonus to complete any content by the way, but I guess you get where I’m coming from.

Slow to Adjust to Issues

The only reasonable explanation of not tackling Shepherd’s is that the current stat and progression curve is close to its end anyway. In that case it obviously doesn’t make sense to get into a solution for Shepherd’s Devotion if the power levels that currently cause the issue won’t be there soon.

Around here however we’ve frequently talked about how slow Cryptic is to adjust to issues. Which means they either don’t have the tools to monitor thinks like “oh look, all endgame teams run around with DR caps on all teammates”, nobody is watching those logs, or they file it internally as low priority. I know Shepherd’s is not a major issue, but it’s still a perfect example of how imbalances in Neverwinter frequently stick around longer than they should.

What’s your take on this topic? Share your thoughts and experience on our social channels, in the comments below, or visit our message board!

Neverwinter UN:Blogged is always looking for writers to contribute to the blog. If you are an active player and search for a way to spread your opinions, analysis, diaries or reviews to more than 75,000 regular visitors, then don’t hesitate and get in touch with us on our contact page or message board! We are currently especially looking for console and PVP content, but that’s not exclusive. There is no frequency requirement, you post how often you want.


j0Shi plays the Neverwinter MMORPG since the open BETA in 2013 and is a regular contributor to the blog and the whole UN:Project. Originally a Guardian Fighter, he has built up ALTs of all classes and plays on BIS/near-BIS level.

4 thoughts on “Isn’t Shepherd’s Devotion the Most Random Broken Thing?

  • September 7, 2018 at 10:29 am

    typo: “is the fast that it scales” sb “is the fact that it scales”

    • September 7, 2018 at 1:40 pm

      Thanks! Will correct asap. Cheers!

  • September 7, 2018 at 5:19 pm

    Typo: You’ve got an “und” where you mean “and” in the first sentence.

  • September 7, 2018 at 11:56 pm

    My AC DC always had Shepherd’s Devotion, as she was built to cast Encounters like At Wills and Dailies like Encounters. It took a lot of thought and planning to build her that way, prioritising Recovery and APG over raw Power. She would hit half as hard as my DO, but more than twice as fast. And she’s been nerfed enough, thank you very much!

    But I agree that still having stuff in the game that procs off buffed stats is bad design and bad planning.

    Building dungeons, which affect ALL players of all levels, on top of the way those badly designed and badly planned buffs affect the End-Game Uber-BIS crowd is beyond incompetent.

    Power Creep is the Death Knell of many games, it seems. It has been mentioned many times, since at least Mod 2. But it seems that most of those staff have moved on and today’s Devs have no clue because they weren’t here back then. That’s why Piercing Damage, SoD etc keeps flipping back and forth. And still no fix to the CW’s broken Blighting Power etc. But lots of back-tracking with Storm Spell.

    Rather than another Mod 6, I’d really like to see a Mega Bug Squash. Once things work they way they are supposed to, and the Tool Tips say what things *actually* do, THEN they could work on Class Balance.


Comments are closed.